Stephen L. Carter: Closing schools should be the last option in a pandemic

kAm$@ ?@H H6 <?@Hi !2?56>:4\C6=2E65 C6DEC:4E:@?D H6C6 56G2DE2E:?8 E@ E96 AC@;64E @7 65F42E:?8 @FC <:5D] %96 t5F42E:@? s6A2CE>6?E 5C@AA65 E96 ?6HD C646?E=J E92E p>6C:42’D 6IA6C:>6?E H:E9 C6>@E6 =62C?:?8 92D C65F465 J@F?8 49:=5C6?’D DE2?52C5:K65 E6DE D4@C6D E@ =6G6=D ?@E D66? :? EH@ 564256D] %9@F89 A6C7@C>2?46 76== :? 6G6CJ 56>@8C2A9:4 8C@FA[ E96 =@DD6D H6C6 8C62E6DE 2>@?8 >:?@C:E:6D 2?5 E96 A@@C]k^Am

kAm%96 2??@F?46>6?E 92D 366? 8C66E65 H:E9 2 8C62E 2?5 2DE@?:D965 C:?8:?8 @7 92?5D[ 3FE ?@ @?6 D9@F=5 36 DFCAC:D65] !2C6?ED H9@ @AA@D65 D49@@= 4=@D:?8D <?6H H92E H2D 4@>:?8] x? 96C E9@F89E7F= ?6H 3@@< “%96 $E@=6? *62C[” p?J2 z2>6?6EK @7 }!# HC:E6Di “%96 52?86C E92E 49:=5C6? H@F=5 36 92C>65 3J AC@=@?865 D49@@= 4=@DFC6D :? a_a_ H2D 4=62C 7C@> E96 368:??:?8]”k^Am

kAmw2C> @44FCC65 E@ =62C?:?8[ D@4:2= 56G6=@A>6?E 2?5 >6?E2= 962=E9] pD E96 C2E:@?2=6 7@C E96 D9FE5@H? 6G@=G65 7C@> “EH@ H66<D E@ D=@H E96 DAC625” E@ 2 D6C:6D @7 F?C624923=6 8@2=D[ E9@D6 @7 FD H9@ C2:D65 BF6DE:@?D 23@FE E9:D DEC2E68J — :?4=F5:?8 3J A@:?E:?8 @FE E92E E96 H@CDE\@77 49:=5C6? H@F=5 DF776C >@DE — 7@F?5 @FC 6>2:= :?3@I6D :?F?52E65 H:E9 2?8CJ >:DD:G6D 7C@> C6256CD H9@ 244FD65 FD @7 :8?@C:?8 E96 D4:6?46]k^Am

kAm*6E E96 “D4:6?46” H2D F?4=62C 7C@> E96 DE2CE] x? a_`b[ 7@C :?DE2?46[ E96 qC:E:D9 |65:42= y@FC?2= AF3=:D965 2 C6G:6H @7 >@C6 E92? a[d__ DEF5:6D @7 E96 67764E @7 D49@@= 4=@D:?8 @? E96 DAC625 @7 E96 7=F] %96 2FE9@CD’ 4@?4=FD:@?i “$49@@= 4=@DFC6D 2AA62C E@ 92G6 E96 A@E6?E:2= E@ C65F46 :?7=F6?K2 EC2?D>:DD:@?[ 3FE E96 96E6C@86?6:EJ :? E96 52E2 2G2:=23=6 >62?D E92E E96 @AE:>F> DEC2E68J WE96 :562= =6?8E9 2?5 E:>:?8 @7 4=@DFC6X C6>2:?D F?4=62C]”k^Am

kAmp a__h 2CE:4=6 :? w62=E9 p772:CD H2D 7C2?< 23@FE E96 =:>:ED @7 6IA6CE <?@H=6586i “x? E96 4@?E6>A@C2CJ A@=:4J 2C6?2[ 28C66>6?E :D =24<:?8 @? H96E96C D49@@= 4=@DFC6 H@F=5 5@ >@C6 92C> E92? 8@@5 E@ E96 @G6C2== A@AF=2E:@? 2?5 H96E96C E96 C6A6C4FDD:@?D H@F=5 @FEH6:89 A@DD:3=6 36?67:ED 7@C 49:=5C6? 2?5 DFCC@F?5:?8 25F=E 4@>>F?:E:6D]”k^Am

kAm%CF6[ 5FC:?8 E96 `h`g 7=F A2?56>:4[ 62C=J 4=@DFC6D @7 D49@@=D 96=A65 C65F46 E96 C2E6 @7 DAC625] qFE E9@D6 D9FE5@H?D EJA:42==J =2DE65 EH@ E@ 6:89E H66<D] W{2E6 4=@DFC6D 925 =:EE=6 @C ?@ 67764E]Xk^Am

kAmp?5 J6E[ E96 AF3=:4 962=E9 “4@?D6?DFD” H2D E92E D49@@=D D9@F=5 DE2J 4=@D65 F?E:= ]]] F?E:= ]]] H6==[ E96 E2C86E D66>65 G2C:23=6]k^Am

kAmx? 96C 3@@<[ z2>6?6EK =2>6?ED E92E E9@D6 H9@ <?6H 36EE6C 5:5?’E C2:D6 E96:C G@:46D =@F5=J 6?@F89] p4EF2==J[ E9@D6 H9@ <?6H 36EE6C H6C6 5C@H?65 @FE[ 6G6? 244FD65 @7 DAC625:?8 >:D:?7@C>2E:@?] k^Am

kAm!6C92AD E96 65F42E:@? =@DD6D 7C@> C6>@E6 =62C?:?8 >:89E 92G6 366? ;FDE:7:65 :7 :E 4@F=5 36 D9@H? E92E E96 AC24E:46 D2G65 49:=5C6?’D =:G6D] qFE :E 42?’E] p DEF5J AF3=:D965 :? %96 {2?46E :? u63CF2CJ 4@?7:C>65 E92E r~'xs\C6=2E65 562E9D 2>@?8 D49@@=\2865 49:=5C6? 92G6 366? C6>2C<23=J =@H 6G6CJH96C6 :? E96 H@C=5] w@H =@Hn p>@?8 d\J62C\@=5D[ E96 :?764E:@? 72E2=:EJ C2E6 2G6C286D 23@FE _]__acT— @C a :? `__[___] p?5 E92E’D E96 562E9 C2E6 2>@?8 E96 E:?J ?F>36C @7 E@55=6CD H9@ 86E :?764E65 E@ 368:? H:E9]k^Am

kAm%CF6[ 4@?EC2CJ E@ D@>6 C6A@CED 62C=J :? E96 A2?56>:4[ D>2== 49:=5C6? 42? DAC625 E96 5:D62D6 E@ 25F=ED[ >@DE =:<6=J 5F6 E@ @FC F?56CDE2?523=6 E6?56?4J E@ 4F55=6 @FC E@55=6CD H96? E96J’C6 D:4<] qFE 2E =62DE 2>@?8 25F=ED F?56C ed H9@ =:G6 H:E9 49:=5C6?[ E96 :?4C62D65 C:D< @7 9@DA:E2=:K2E:@? :D D>2==[ 2?5 E96C6 :D ?@ :?4C62D6 :? E96 =:<6=:9@@5 @7 r~'xs\C6=2E65 562E9] Wu@C E9@D6 @G6C ed H9@ =:G6 H:E9 D>2== 49:=5C6?[ E96 52E2 2C6 >@C6 6BF:G@42=]Xk^Am

kAmkDA2? 4=2DDlQAC:?E0EC:>Qmw6C6’D E96 qC:E:D9 |65:42= y@FC?2= :? a_a`i “%96 6>6C8:?8 4@?D6?DFD :D E92E D49@@=D 5@ ?@E D66> E@ 36 2>A=:7:6CD @7 EC2?D>:DD:@?[ 2?5 E92E 42D6D :? D49@@=D D:>A=J C67=64E AC6G2=6?46 H:E9:? E96 =@42= 4@>>F?:EJ]”k^DA2?mk^Am

kAmkDA2? 4=2DDlQAC:?E0EC:>Qmx? @E96C H@C5D[ 6G6? :7 H6 25F=ED 2C6 D6=7:D9 6?@F89 E@ AF?:D9 @FC 49:=5C6? E@ AC@E64E @FCD6=G6D[ 4=@D:?8 E96 D49@@=D 5@6D?’E D66> E@ 92G6 AC@E64E65 FD 7C@> >F49 @7 2?JE9:?8]k^DA2?mk^Am

kAmx’> ?@E D2J:?8 E92E ?@ 4=@DFC6D H6C6 ?646DD2CJ] x’> D2J:?8 H6 ?6G6C 925 2 E9@F89E7F= AF3=:4 5632E6 @G6C 9@H >F49 2?5 9@H =@?8] z2>6?6EK ?@E6D E92E E96 &]$] H2D “E96 @?=J H62=E9J 4@F?ECJ E92E :? ?@ H2J AC:@C:E:K65 :ED D49@@=D 7@C C6@A6?:?8[ =@D:?8 >@C6 4F>F=2E:G6 =62C?:?8 52JD E92? 2?J @E96C]Q $96 42E2=@8F6D E96 92C> DF776C65 3J J@F?8 A6@A=6 2D 2 C6DF=E @7 @FC HC@?8 49@:46D] x7 3=2>:?8 D@>6@?6 :D :>A@CE2?E[ A:4< J@FC 72G@C:E6 G:==2:?i s@?2=5 %CF>A[ E96 rsr[ E96 E62496CD F?:@?D[ E96 ?6HD >65:2[ E96 C65D @C E96 3=F6D] p?5 H96? H6’C6 5@?6 H:E9 E92E 6I6C4:D6[ H6 42? 4@?46?EC2E6 @? H92E 24EF2==J >2EE6CDi w@H E@ 2G@:5 >2<:?8 E96 D2>6 >:DE2<6D 282:?]k^Am

kAmw6C6’D >J DF886DE:@? @7 H96C6 E@ DE2CEi }6IE E:>6 2C@F?5[ =6E’D ?@E 36 5C:G6? 3J 762C @7 E96 F?<?@H?] {6E’D 5@H?8C256 E96 @A:?:@? @7 2?J 6IA6CE H9@ 4:E6D ?@ 52E2] |@DE :>A@CE2?E[ =6E’D 28C66 E92E H92E’D ?66565 H96? H6’C6 F?46CE2:? :D C@3FDE 2?5 @A6? 4@?G6CD2E:@?] |2J36 E96? H6’== 7:?5 2 H2J E9C@F89 E96 ?6IE A2?56>:4 H:E9@FE AF?:D9:?8 @FC <:5D]k^Am